Set Building in Sports Cards: Why It Matters and How to Get Started

Hello, collectors! Coleman Bennett here, owner of Ontario’s Card Corner. One of the most rewarding aspects of sports card collecting is set building. Whether it’s the thrill of hunting for that last elusive card or the satisfaction of completing a full set, this part of the hobby has been cherished for decades.

In this blog, we’ll explore the different types of set builders in depth, highlight some of the most impressive graded sets in the PSA registry, and discuss why set building remains an essential and fulfilling part of sports card collecting.

1. What Is Set Building?

Set building involves collecting every card from a specific release, series, or subset. While the concept is simple, the way collectors approach it can vary widely.

A. Types of Set Builders

1. Base Set Builders

  • Overview: Base set builders focus on completing the core cards of a particular release. These sets usually consist of the numbered cards that form the backbone of a product’s checklist.

  • Example: Completing the 2022 Topps Baseball base set, which includes 660 cards split between Series 1 and Series 2.

  • Why It’s Popular:

    • Base sets are the most accessible and affordable way to enjoy set building.

    • They provide a comprehensive view of a product’s theme, whether it’s an annual sports release or a special series like Topps Heritage.

  • Challenges:

    • With larger sets, finding the final few cards can be tricky, especially short-printed base cards.

2. Master Set Builders

  • Overview: A master set includes the base cards plus all parallels, inserts, autographs, and other variations from a release. This type of set building requires a significant investment of time and money.

  • Example: A master set of 2021-22 Upper Deck Hockey would include:

    • The full base set.

    • Young Guns rookie cards.

    • Parallels like Clear Cut, Exclusives (/100), and High Gloss (/10).

    • Inserts such as Canvas and Dazzlers.

    • Autographed cards and memorabilia patches.

  • Why It’s Popular:

    • Master sets showcase the full creative scope of a release, from common cards to rare grails.

    • They’re incredibly satisfying to display as a complete collection.

  • Challenges:

    • High costs due to the rarity of certain cards, such as parallels and autographs.

    • Limited print runs can make some pieces nearly impossible to find.

3. Player Collectors

  • Overview: These collectors focus on assembling every card of a specific player. This could include base cards, inserts, autographs, and one-of-ones.

  • Example: A Connor McDavid collector might pursue:

    • His Young Guns rookie card.

    • Every Future Watch Auto and parallel.

    • Rare memorabilia patches from The Cup.

    • Serial-numbered and short-printed cards from each year of his career.

  • Why It’s Popular:

    • It’s a deeply personal way to collect, allowing fans to focus on their favorite athlete.

    • Player collections often grow into impressive showcases of a single career.

  • Challenges:

    • One-of-one cards and rare parallels can make it impossible to “complete” a player’s collection.

    • Competition from other collectors can drive up prices.

4. Themed Set Builders

  • Overview: These collectors build custom sets based on a specific theme or category rather than a traditional checklist.

  • Example Themes:

    • Hall of Fame rookie cards across all sports.

    • Cards featuring a favorite team, such as the 1992 Toronto Blue Jays championship roster.

    • Special subsets like the 1976 Topps Basketball "All-Time Leaders" series.

  • Why It’s Popular:

    • Themed sets allow for creativity and personalization.

    • They’re often focused on cards with significant historical or emotional value.

  • Challenges:

    • Creating a checklist can be subjective and require deep knowledge of the hobby.

    • Finding rare cards for niche themes can take years.

5. Graded Set Builders

  • Overview: Graded set builders seek to complete a set where every card is professionally graded, often aiming for consistency in grade levels.

  • Example: Completing a 1952 Topps Baseball set with all cards graded PSA 8 or higher.

  • Why It’s Popular:

    • Graded sets offer a tangible sense of accomplishment and a clear measure of quality.

    • They’re excellent for long-term investment, as the cards’ grades are preserved.

  • Challenges:

    • Cost can be prohibitive, especially for older cards in high grades.

    • Certain cards in a set may be difficult to find in consistent grades.

6. Subset Builders

  • Overview: Subset collectors focus on completing a smaller portion of a release, such as inserts or short-printed cards.

  • Example: Completing the 2020 Panini Prizm Football "Color Blast" insert set.

  • Why It’s Popular:

    • Subsets often feature unique designs and themes, making them visually appealing.

    • They’re more manageable than building full or master sets.

  • Challenges:

    • Subsets are often rare or short-printed, making them difficult to complete.

2. Why Set Building Matters

A. Preserving Hobby Traditions

Set building has been a cornerstone of the hobby since its inception. It’s a way to honour the history and heritage of card collecting while creating a personal connection to each release.

B. Building Knowledge and Expertise

As you build sets, you naturally learn more about the players, teams, and nuances of each release. This deeper understanding enhances your appreciation of the hobby.

C. A Rewarding Challenge

There’s nothing quite like the feeling of finding that last card to complete your set. It’s a tangible goal that combines the joy of collecting with a sense of accomplishment.

D. Community Engagement

Set building fosters camaraderie among collectors. Trading, sharing tips, and celebrating milestones with fellow enthusiasts make the journey even more enjoyable.

Final Thoughts

Set building is one of the most fulfilling ways to engage with the hobby. It’s about more than completing a checklist; it’s about connecting with the history and community of sports card collecting. Whether you’re building a base set, chasing down rare inserts, or crafting a custom theme, the journey is always worth it.

At Ontario’s Card Corner, we’re here to help you on your set-building journey. Need advice, missing a few cards, or just want to share your progress? Reach out to us or visit us at the next card show. Let’s keep the tradition of set building alive together!

Happy collecting!
Coleman Bennett
Owner, Ontario’s Card Corner

Back to blog